The Art of Hosting

This is a conversation thread as it happened on the AoH emaillist. It started with a question by Alexis:
 
anyone knows / has experiences with Art of Hosting in formal education?
Any good case practices out there in using the methods in primary and secondary schools?
Or even outside school but with young  people (under 14 year olds)?
 
Anything you could share in this area, would be very valuable.
 
I am currently supporting the Teach for Austria - Learning Responsible and she got very interested in bringing in AoH in the teacher training that they are providing in summer. For this objective though it would be great if we could build on best case practices from the community.
 
Thank you much in advance.
 
Hugs from Vienna,
Alexis
----------------
Yes...
 
I've run Open Spaces, World Cafe's and circles with many young people.  Ashley Cooper (who may be on this list, but if not, you can Google her) has worked for many years with children within the education system.  There are many practitioners with this kind of experience.  Do you have a specific question?
 
Chris
---------------
Hi Alexia.
 
This may not quite hit the mark of what you are asking. However, it was some important learning that I put into writing on being with my first-grade son and his class. Fresh from this morning.
 
For inspiration, and I suppose the glowing joy of a dad on this day.
 
I'm also beginning some work with a friend in Seattle specifically for educators. I'll appreciate hearing what others offer here.
 
Greetings from Utah.
 
Tenneson
---------------
Hi Alexis,
 
I use Art of Hosting methodologies and other tools in all of my graduate level teaching.
 
That's not the same, I think, as doing Art of Hosting in formal education. Most of my classes are not explicitly about teaching dialogical processes.  So we do spend some time talking about the practices and making them explicit, often students use them in their "presentations" back to the class, but I would not say I "teach" Art of Hosting in these classes.
 
Happy to talk with you more about this.
 
Cheers,
 
Bob
---------------

Yes -
I train educators to 'host learning'.  We are implementing AoH (Participatory Learning) in community colleges (in NM, KY, OH, MI, and RI - these are all USA states), adult basic education and literacy programs (MT, OH, KY, MI, WV, RI, NM, OK - more USA states), and in a few 1 - 6th grade schools (6 to 12 years old - Texas).

In addition, my 10 month Transforming Learning course in which educators are trained to use AoH is hosted using AoH.  The educators first love AoH/Participatory Learning as it supports their own learning - and then see its value in hosting interactive learner-driven learning environments, creating new ways for to deliver curriculum and build core standards, and for building of critical social capital skills that can serve the lifelong learning needs of all individuals  to thrive in whatever the future (family, community, education, employment) might bring.


Using AoH is being looked at as a core capacity for establishing and supporting learning communities in community colleges (mostly aimed at vocational learning), specifically in Michigan, and I've been asked to present AoH as a means for developing learning communities in community colleges in Montana this spring.

I've presented and demonstrated Circle and World Cafe/AoH (as a 'taste' of Participatory Learning) at numerous national and regional conferences targeting services with: adult education, literacy, community college developmental education, and English Language Learning (ELL) education.  I hear good things back from these participants - even with just a conference session sampling of AoH!  Educators are taking back Circle and Cafe technologies and immediately implementing them!

While at ALIA Europe Institute ('10 & '11), I held a several conversations about AoH in education with educators at all levels from the UK, Netherlands, Italy, Denmark, and South Africa.
I believe Toke has been working with schools in Denmark in using AoH.
There was a short spirt of discussion in the fall '11 on the AoH listserv about AoH in education, but I was unable to participate very much due to a heavy travel schedule.  If there is an interest in having a Skype conversation about AoH in education, I'd be willing to host that conversation.


Looking forward to build a great cohort group to share information and implementation, educator and learner feedback, and supportive research.

Laura Weisel

---------------

What an interesting thread, thanks Alexis, for starting this.
I can offer maybe only partly personal experiences you need, but learnings can be transferred.
For all my training in the European Commission, almost independent of content, I am "teaching" using AoH. This is of course adult education, but sure kids love it just the same, following the reports from my children, where they do not have many participatory choices…
So always starting with circle in the morning, and a good calling question (and sometimes the circle is in cafe setting, if there are too many), then a small inquiry in pairs or triads, or a table talk, to get them warm on the subject, and only after the first harvest the information comes from us.
Any 'information" technical or not, comes in slices, like maximum 15 minutes, followed by a few questions and then a "table talk", meaning one round of cafe conversation for people to bring the heard subject into their own context.  That's the pattern that can lead through the whole training.
We harvest and display carefully, and most of the time the distilled learnings of the group would write the manual. Each time I make that observation, even on issues like strategic planning, indicator setting, you name it, people already know how to best apply. But instead of listening to one person chewing on a topic, and maybe the others shutting down attention or going to maximum second level of listening mode, with active creation of the topics themselves they all gain understanding much more quickly.
I would say one of the differences with pupils might be speed, they are often done faster in a round than adults.
I also can recommend to contact  Silvia Angel, who has run world cafes in schools to find out about ideal education, she also has made a movie on this, and ran a world cafe including teachers and pupils in the Bregenzer Salon in Austria on this last summer. Here are her two movies from schools in Sweden and Australia.
And again from Austria, in Bregenz AoH has been used in a high school recently in a more prominent way. Carmen Feuchtner is responsible for the project.
And last but not least there are formal working groups now in the department of education in the European Commission to get to more innovation going in schools. As far as I know there are national education officials involved, and the meeting organisers use and teach AoH methods as an operating system. Some people on this list are involved in this, but I can find out more details about it from colleagues, if this is interesting.
Warm greetings,
Ursula Hillbrand
Brussels
-----------------
Thank you Alexis for your question!
And Laura, I would be in for a skype circle around this thread.
Just some quick thoughts now:
- We have started experimenting here in Berlin with AoH in a school activity (in the afternoon for 90min) this semester. We have so far hosted 5 sessions with boys between 7th and 9th grade and have invited adults for this Future Learning Space. We have tried to host a Pro Action Café where we were facing a major time challenge. You can read up on our experience on our blog (so far the reports are only in German: 
An interesting question in this work here is emerging: How does the Hub concept look like in a school?
- In Germany there is the term Demokratiepädagogik (Democracy Pedagogy) which uses similar methods like Art of Hosting, for example there has been a major state-funded project in Germany a few years ago that has produced lots of useful material for teachers and education consultants called: Demokratie lernen und leben  http://blk-demokratie.de/ 
- Within that field, people have translated the AI process for example into something that is called WeLab (Wir-Werkstatt) where I have used parts in my work at the school:  http://dkhw.de/dkhw_shop/catalog/product_info.php?products_id=83 
- The Berlin Open Space cooperative has been using Open Space with children a lot, this is just one example with 40 kids (some of them were still in kindergarden):  http://boscop.org/pages/82-beispiel-hort 
- With a team mate from the Future Learning Space, we will be hosting the second Knowledge Lab, a cousin of Open Space, next week which is like a community skillshare event that Lauren has been working on in London for her final KaosPilots project. This is a video of the Knowledge Lab:  http://vimeo.com/38000229 
It is a nice method to involve different generations, parents, the community around the school, etc. into an informal learning activity
- And Alexis, reading the context, I was just reminded about the Archives of the Future Congress in Bregenz in 2008 where we visited different school innovators around the Lake Constance (these are the different places: http://www.adz-netzwerk.de/Samstag.php). This area is really an education innovation hub. This might be an excellent area to invite Teach for Austria participants on a hosted Learning Journey.
I am ready to co-host ;-)
...and you might also want to connect with Nanna and others from Denmark who have recently hosted an AoH for teachers.
Best,
Frauke
------------------
hello all, 
I am on the same way with my türkisch and arabic students in a goverment school in Berlin Moabit. They are in the age between 12 and 18 years. 
You can follow our storytelling on this blogs (in German) Jugendliche bloggen aus der Schule: http://slowlearning.wordpress.com/  and Schulgeschichten der Lehrerin:            http://storyburger.wordpress.com/
My work follows two lines...
In the daily lessons,  I am a host in a well designed learning enviroment, which invites the kids and the grown up to do what they want to do. Together we developed some pattern for success. More and more the children are able to use the knowledge of participatory leadership and design thinking to create there own structures and learning enviroments.
Please have a look in a videoclip  in german language,  about my session on the edu camp in Bielefeld in Nov. 2011 http://www.youtube.com/user/educamptv#p/u/14/ShtUSf7nCkw 
Another line is my work with the girls and boys which are the class captains and school captains. In a weekly meeting they learn step by step the attitude of a host and ways of particiaptory leadership. In September 2011, Frauke Godat an me hosted  a small AoH Training with 40 Young Changemakers on our Gemeinschaftsschule. 
It is fantastic to work together with this Kids, again early tomorrow in the morning, so I have to go to sleep... 
hugs to this wonderful community,
Gertrud from Berlin
----------------
Tenneson

This is amazing what you are you doing. For me it only confirms that the art of hosting is the part of who we are. What is needed is to remember who are are and how to practice this in every aspect of our being.
Silas

Views: 312

Replies to This Conversation

Such a rich and exciting conversation, everyone. 

I, too, have been using AOH for the last decade in learning and retreat events for educators, consultants, and leaders in our public school district (K to Gr 12), and am now coaching teachers to use it with students in classrooms, to engage our students in the co-design of their learning, to authentically and meaningfully engage our students. 

My next "jump in" is to offer this training to our students.  We have a global cafe in one high school and a growing international global network using technology, virtual classrooms, in another.  Helping youth develop this practice, feel at ease in this practice, remember this practice, for me, contributes to a wise, compassionate and humane global citizenry.

Not only do I look forward to this ongoing conversation, but also, to the potential to partner with you in this work - again, meshing our experiences, cultures, perspectives, and hearts.

Thank you,

Katharine

And it seems the conversation is not over yet...

I use AoH techniques in my leadership, ethics and other training programs at a local polytechnic. I'm not teaching the techniques though. 
I'm also working with some dialogue practitioners at the university introducing AoH to faculty & grad students. 
Happy to shate

John (Jack) Donovan
------------------
Dear Alexis,
we have run a first process with aoh methods with 16year olds and do work in children participation since quite some time. The process with the 16 year olds has been easy, they worked towards creating their own projects - what are your more specific questions? We are in Austria / Vorarlberg ...
best regards,
Carmen
-----------------
Hi Alexis,
 
I used OS in enaging grade eight boys in conversations around masculinity.  The following is the abstract:
 

Abstract:

The purpose of this research project was to engage boys in conversations that matter to them around the theme of masculinity and male youth culture. The research investigated the different ways boys collectively narrate how they are socialized to gender roles as a group. This exploration was in response to questions from Middle School staff and students curious about how to include boys in dialogue around gender-based violence prevention strategies.

The organizational design process of Open Space Technology was used to investigate how boys take up the invitation to explore the often thorny issues of how notions of masculinities shape their identity and how boys examine the potential limitations particular notions of masculinity may impose. The research suggests that Open Space Technology created a space within a school setting for multi-storied accounts of boys' relationships to masculinities to emerge.
Since this time, I have used AoH methods, including OS to create dialogue around mental health issues and strategies, and violence prevention for young folks, parents and teachers within the school district.  Challenging and rewarding work!
 
All the best, 
Shannon
----------------

RE: AoH methods used to assess the gifts/assets of high risk,  inner city male, school age, youth. In this case, a large urban school district enters into an agreement to use AoH as a means of discovery. Their plan - A new program that integrates a “gifts” focus along with the traditional “deficiency” based servicing focus. This project was a discovery of GIFTS.

In my experience, AoH practices can be used successfully in large urban schools at all grade levels. AoH creates a social architecture for learning, connection and trust.

The gifts, thoughts and creativity of the students were revealed through the following four questions and three café rounds:

What are you passionate about?

What do you like to learn?

What are you good at?

What do you know how to do that you would be willing to teach others?

 

Below is an excerpt from the Harvest:

HARVEST

 

 

Young Men’s Focus Group Sessions May 18-19, 2011

Submitted by - Dan Joyner, Stan Ross, Rosie Merkt

Date:  June 2, 2011

Schools – Covedale, Walnut, Hays

Methodology – Peer Circle, Six Conversations, World Café – These three methods sometimes called “social technologies” were used interchangeably during the sessions. World Café offered the best chance to obtain the greatest amount of data in the time allotted to each session. Peer Circle and Six Conversations created sufficient opportunity for both convergent and divergent processes needed for building relationships and to amplify the conditions for learning.

The student, in every case (100%) was engaged in session activities. The processes empowered the students and enabled an “openness” that led to them freely offering their ideas. The processes seemed to create the conditions for respect.

Prior to the start of the sessions, the facilitators, Dan Joyner, Stan Ross and Rosie Merkt, discussed various roles and agreed to use a participatory action learning process. We had no contact prior to the first session.

We paid particular attention to “context” during the sessions i.e., listening deeply, we asked ourselves - are the questions personal and thought provoking, is there ample focus on possibilities and is there a focus on place and being in the moment. Not only did the experience yield a great deal of data, but we also noticed a real sense of “bigness” toward the event purpose, from among everybody in the room.

 

Other Observations:

Depth – Through our observations, reflections and analysis of the café tablecloths and session artifacts, several deeper patterns have become evident; “life matters” to the students and “they care”. We could clearly see that they “have a heart”.

Connections – The processes work, we could see the connections among the boys develop throughout each session. The boys recognized their commonality over their differences. At the conclusion, we asked Covedale and Walnut “Did you meet another boy today you didn’t already know before this meeting?” Covedale 4 of 12 said yes and at Walnut 12 of 12 said yes.

Conversations were respectful – We immediately noticed the tone/energy in the room, it made both boys and facilitators feel relaxed. There were no notable behavior issues. At Hays, the boys needed a little more coaching around the processes. Hays had a security staff member join our group. He was friendly and met the facilitator at the desk before the session He escorted the boys to and from the session with a military type language. He seemed very well suited for his work. During the session he commented that he noticed a difference in the tone/energy in the room and noticed the same relaxed feel emanating from the boys and himself. All the boys displayed exemplary behavior toward each other and the facilitators.

Professional development – During each session, the facilitators spent time in a small affinity group reflecting on their learning, observing the room, collating data, connecting ideas, paying attention to the processes and sharing knowledge about our own work, hopes and aspirations…

Warm Regards,

Dan Joyner

and still some more...

Hi all!

Sharing some experiences:

I've been using some AoH methods in a high school setting, in the brazilian public school system. I teach two 50 minute classes a week, to each group of approximately 30 teenagers (15-17 years-old). Due to the general conditions of the system, I have to use homoeopathic doses. What I've been doing is basically call a circle once in a while, and use some variations of open space with harvest, to treat philosophical subjects.

I've had some amazing experiences. This has to do, I believe, with a transformation of the usual intellectualised model into something that involves feelings, emotions, and body. When I change the usual teacher-and-blackboard model into a circle and open it, the whole dynamics of the class changes from something arid and impersonal to a space-time where real people are talking about real things, eye to eye. There are tears, laughs, and truths spoken. Something we carry for life, and not only put in a drawer somewhere and forget.

But it's all very tentative, and I haven't quite got the hang of connecting these happenings with theoretical learning, which is also necessary. I find that the AoH methods work best to solve practical problems (like garbage, behaviour or rules discussion) and personal issues with the students, but when it comes to learning theoretical stuff it doesn't quite get to the point. But I think this is mostly due to my lack of experience with the tools, and to the lack of interest of students about theoretical stuff.

However, the old teacher-and-blackboard model doesn't work well either, when it comes to theoretical learning. During traditional classes, most of the students tend to be either asleep or thinking about other things, so I guess the problem is not really with the AoH tools, nor totally with my lack of experience with them. The AoH methods still leave me with a surplus in comparison to the blackboard model. Anyway, I think formal education can greatly benefit from the AoH practice, and that with a well-trained host the sky is the limit.

This is my experience, so far. Thanks for calling this discussion.

André.

more to read...

In Illinois there was a lot of discussion about “Social and Emotional Learning” and how AoH is a model of social and emotional learning for adults (and kids).  We talked a lot about how important it is that the adults in a system be learning together in support of kids (and families) learning. 

 

Caryn Curry is one in Illinois who’s done a tremendous amount with creating environments for social and emotional learning.

teresa

RSS

© 2024   Created by Rowan.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service